Sunday, January 20, 2008

Is anyone reading this blog?

Andrew Sullivan, January 20, 2008, in "The hardball master has taught Hillary well"
My own sense is that Hillary Clinton’s initial gaffe – implicitly analogising herself to Lyndon Johnson and Obama to Martin Luther King – was an accident. She meant to make the point that she is a doer and he is merely a speaker. But inevitably it came off as condescending – as if black people always need white leaders to gain their own rights.


Headland, January 15, 2008, in "Playing the 'They are Playing the Race Card' Card":

Was this the plan all along? Perhaps, but it is just as likely that this new strategy is a desperate response to the fallout from her grotesque gaffe. It is quite possible, at least initially, that Hillary only meant to say that Obama is a man of words and she is a woman of action. In comparing herself to LBJ, she took her point to be the modest one of suggesting that, while not an inspirational speaker, she is an effective leader. By giving Obama the analogous role to King's, however, and by intending to insult Obama as ineffective, she incredibly failed to draw the obvious implication that she would thereby diminish the patron saint of civil rights.

Labels: , , , ,

|| headland, 11:40 PM

3 Comments:

Am now ...

Cheers! A5
Anonymous Anonymous, at March 5, 2008 at 10:48 AM  
Welcome, A5!
Blogger headland, at March 5, 2008 at 11:04 AM  
Askel5?
Blogger headland, at March 7, 2008 at 6:57 PM  

Add a comment

« Newest Posts | Older Post: and in other news... »
| Older Post: Hillary's Task Force Schemes: P.S. Who is P.S.? »
| Older Post: Charlie Wilson's New War »
| Older Post: The Vegas Debate and the Framing of the Campaign »
| Older Post: Playing the 'They are Playing the Race Card' Card »
| Older Post: Hillary's Meta-Racist Campaign Against Obama »
| Older Post: What was the Message Hillary Clinton Intended to S... »
| Older Post: Yushchenko or Else? »
| Older Post: Impressing the Saudis and Winning the War »
| Older Post: Increased Incursions into Iran Incite Insecurity »